Skip to main content
News and blog
News

Civil Service Commission publishes strategic review of Business Appointment Rules for senior civil servants and special advisers

Published 17 November 2026

The independent Civil Service Commission has published a review of the Business Appointment Rules (BARs) for senior civil servants, diplomats, and special advisers.

The review, requested by ministers, sets out recommendations to modernise how post-government exits are managed to ensure the Rules remain robust, proportionate and fit for purpose in a modern working environment.

The government’s Business Appointment Rules, which apply to all civil servants, have not been substantively updated since they were first published in 1975. 

Under the current system, the same lengthy process applies widely and does not distinguish sharply enough between ‘high risk’ applications and others. The proposed reforms aim to ensure that roles carrying a genuine risk of conflict of interest remain tightly controlled, while enabling greater movement between government and other sectors for lower risk cases. 

First Civil Service Commissioner, Baroness Gisela Stuart, said:

“Our review finds that the very people with skills most sought after by the Civil Service can be deterred from joining by concerns about how the Rules will bind them when they exit, while those leaving government report frustrations with the process that would put them off returning – both of which compromise the ability of the current and future governments to deliver for the country”.

The Commission’s report proposes cost-neutral practical methods for resolving these challenges, including:

  • Amendments to the Rules and conditions to clearly enable available flexibilities to reserve the most stringent conditions for the most risky cases, particularly to address the current imposition of two year conditions described by one interviewee as ‘absurdly disproportionate’. 
  • Process and culture changes to establish awareness of the Rules from the onboarding stage, remove duplicative stages and administrative bottlenecks, and establish firm expectations for, and transparency around, expected departmental practice and timeliness.
  • Compliance improvements to enhance accountability, including through enhanced public transparency of employers’ agreements to conditions and use of upcoming reforms to the Civil Service Code to introduce greater alignment across the two frameworks.

The Commission sends quarterly correspondence to Cabinet Office ministers on its operations and its views on the application of the Rules, and will continue to report on progress.

Read: Modernising exit: A review into the Business Appointment Rules for senior civil servants and special advisers

Read: First Civil Service Commissioner to the Chancellor of the Duchy of Lancaster and the Cabinet Secretary (Tuesday 13 November 2026)

Read: Business Appointments Rules advice published by the Commission